Build Your Box of Cookies-Milford, OH

Warning: all these cookies may be habit-forming.  

Almond Toffee Chip:  A cookie and candy in one by combining buttery toffee, Guittard semi-sweet chocolate chips, and toasted almonds make this creation exclusively Blue Chip. A fabulous dessert!

Blue Chip Joy, aka JOY:  Take almonds, semi-sweet chocolate chips, with a touch of coconut!  It brings joy to the coconut and chocolate lover!  

Blue Chip Royale:  Take almonds, toffee brickle and creamy white chocolate chips, and you've got an imperial tasting cookie fit for kings and queens.

Chocolate Chip, aka The Big Kahuna:  the grand slam, the most incredible chocolate chip cookie you will ever taste. This cookie is the one to stand the test of time. Yummy to the last bite and our customers have voted best cookie in over ten cities.

Chocolate Chip Macadamia:  Semi-sweet chocolates with Hawaiian macadamia nuts shipped from the big island! Aloha. 

Chocolate Chip M&M:  A colorful chocolate chip cookie combined with the famous Mars candy.  Each cookie baked with seasonal M&M's throughout the year. 

Chocolate Chip Walnut:  Our famous chocolate chip cookies baked with walnuts for a crispy, crunchy, nutty delight.

Cinnamon Delight, aka Snickerdoodle: Our sugar cookie infused with cinnamon and spice that has a profile that’s light and airy with great flavor. A favorite for many! Snicker-snap-snicker-doodle. This light and delicious cookie, coated with pure cinnamon, is a "Cinful" creation! 

Cookies & Cream, aka OMG:  We take two famous cookies and combine them into one!  The famous Oreo Cookie and Blue Chip Cookie Sugar Cookies...and there you have, Cookie and Cream, with of course a touch of Blue Chip Cookie recipe magic.

Lemon Delight:  Zesty lemons is added to our sugar dough to make a winter day feel like summer and it is a "taste bud" delight. 

Oatmeal Raisin:  Fresh oats, raisins, with a touch of coconut makes Blue Chip's Oatmeal Raisin the best in the country.

Peanut Butter: Our signature dough married with premium creamy smooth peanut butter for that rich peanut-buttery goodness.  This is a little crunch on the outside with that soft peanut butter taste on the inside.

Peanut Butter Surprise: A Peanut Butter Cookie with a Surprise! Ok the surprise in Milk Chocolate Chips.  

Sugar Old-Fashioned:  Our fabulous old fashioned sugar dough rolled in pure cane sugar and then baked.  Enjoy it plain and simple or other variations.

Sugar with Buttercream Icing: Our old-fashion sugar cookie with buttercream icing spread over the cookie.

Sugar Iced with Seasonal Sprinkles: Three layers of sweetness, our Sugar Old-Fashioned, Buttercream vanilla icing on top and then, finale is colorful sprinkles!

Sugar with Seasonal Sprinkles: Favorite amongst our younger fans and those who are young at heart which we all should be. Instead of rolling our sugar cookie in just sugar we roll it in seasonal sprinkles for that perfect treat.

Triple Chocolate, aka Brookie:  Strictly for chocoholics. Milk chocolate, semi-sweet chocolate, and bittersweet chocolate together into a rich cakey chocolatey chocolate cookie which is the texture of a brownie.  First made famous on Fisherman's Wharf.  The Black & White is a variation of this cookie.

White Chocolate Chip: Guittard white chocolates replace the semi-sweet and become the centerpiece for this light, creamy, and delicious cookie.

White Chocolate Chip Macadamia Nut, aka MAC: What Blue Chip Cookies is known for across the country. "The first bakery to introduce the White Chocolate Chip Macadamia to the public. Our very own creation dates to 1982. This buttery rich cookie with white chocolate pieces surrounded by macadamia nuts is truly decadent. 

For Pure Cookie Joy! 

Our cookies, made with the finest ingredients, is what makes Blue Chip Cookies one the best cookies in the country.  We don’t compromise on any of ingredients: real sweet butter, pure vanilla, macadamia nuts from Hawaii, specially milled flour, cane sugar, and whole eggs.  We have no trans fats or preservatives. 

Hours of Operation, open to Public
Monday-Friday, 11 AM -4:00 PM.

We package two same flavor cookies, to each Blue Chip Cookies’ proprietary bag.  We never mix our flavors!

Freeze for the Future:  If you cannot eat all your cookies within two days, we recommend you leave them in our sealed bag and freeze! Do not refrigerate as this will dry the cookies out. Take your cookies out of the freezer 15-20 minutes before serving to thaw and enjoy.  Also, you can put them in the microwave in 10-12 seconds increments until they are just warm.

Planning for the future? No problem. Orders can be placed up to 60 days in advance! 

Nut Allergy Notice: Due to our cookie baking and handling process, all our cookies come in may come contact with tree nuts or nut oils either through baking pans or our baking team. All products have major food allergens (wheat, milk, soy, eggs) and baked with exposure to Tree Nuts/Peanuts. 

4/4/2019 – What is the shelf life of Blue Chip cookies if stored in the freezer?

Response From Blue Chip Cookies Direct: We have tested up to 2 years in the freezer, if the cookies stay sealed in our Blue Chip Bags, assuming the bag is not ripped or the cookies are not exposed to air, they taste fantastic. We recommend eating within 6 months, but as long as frozen and in their bags, they maintain freshness and deliciousness.

4/12/2017 – What Allergies associated with Blue Chip Cookies?

Response From Blue Chip Cookies Direct: Nut Allergy Notice: Due to our baking and handling process, all of products and team of bakers come into contact with tree nuts or nut oils. Please be aware of this if you have any allergic reaction to these products.

All cookies have major food allergens (wheat, milk, soy, eggs).

2/13/2014 – What is the Nutritional Value of a Blue Chip Cookie?

Response From Blue Chip Cookies Direct: Although we have over 35 cookie variation we have found that the nutritional values are very similar for our all cookies, with exception of iced cookies.

Overall Nutritional Values
Calories 270 Calories from Fat 110
% Daily Value
Total Fat 12g 18%
Saturated Fat 7g 35%
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 35mg 12%
Sodium 270mg 11%
Total Carbohydrate 37g 12%
Dietary Fiber 1g 4%
Sugars 23g
Protein 3g

Please visit our main site and look at nutritional values in the footer.

2/5/2014 – How many cookie flavors do you have?

Response From Blue Chip Cookies Direct: We actually have over 40 varieties and we add cookies flavors all the time. If you have an idea, let us know. Look under single flavor assortments or review the information of all the current cookie flavors under the Ingredient tab.

2/5/2014 – What are the ingredients for a Blue Chip Cookie?

Response From Blue Chip Cookies Direct: As you know, Blue Chip Cookies has more than 40 different cookies, and we have endless amounts of variation for those cookies. However, our cookies are made with two basic types of dough:

Our basic brown sugar dough, which is for most of our cookies with the exception of our sugar cookies.

BLUE CHIP BASIC COOKIE DOUGH: Enriched wheat flour bleached (flour, niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), molasses, sugar, butter (pasteurized cream and salt), eggs, baking soda, salt, natural vanilla extract.


Sugar Cookie Dough: No molasses or vanilla extract.