‹ Continue Shopping

Secure Checkout

  • 1Log In or Register
  • 2Shipping & Billing Info
  • 3Review, Pay & Submit

Shop

Security Seals
Navigate:  RETURN TO STOREFRONT / Our Cookie Flavors By the Box
During November and December we reduce the number of cookie flavors to our top 15 flavors, so we can meet the demand during the Holidays.  Don't worry, Eat Cookies! They will all be back in January 2021.  

Sugar Iced is a favorite, but very labor intensive, we do have it available in the MyWay, if you want to purchase up to 4 cookies in an assortment.

*During this time we have a reduced staff due to the requirements of the state of OH. You can always call us and we can see what we can do.

All our cookies are made with real cane sugar, pure vanilla, whole eggs, sweet butter, specially milled flour, only the finest chocolates, gourmet chocolates.


Our Cookie Flavors By the Box

Peppermint White Chocolate Chip Cookie THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
14 Cookies-This is an amazing cookie! Peppermint candy cane pieces mixed with smooth white chocolate chips, with an emulsion boost of peppermint that shouts boldy, "Merry and Bright!"
Ship to multiple addresses
$38.50

Almond Toffee Chip made with slivered almonds, toffee chocolate bits and Guittard Chocolate Semi-Sweet THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
12 Cookies-Almond Toffee-A cookie and candy in one!
Ship to multiple addresses
$38.50

Ocean Spray Blueberries and Cranberries, plus Guittard White Chocolate  Chips THUMBNAIL
Specialty flavors could take 203 additional shipping day vs. core flavors.
The Best Patriotic Cookie for America. A combination of 4 ingredients that light up your taste buds like a fine wine, cranberries, cherries, blueberries and white chocolate chips!
Ship to multiple addresses
$38.50

Black and White Cookies THUMBNAIL
14 Cookies~The Black & White is a sinfully rich and delicious cookie made with bittersweet chocolate and white chocolate.
On Vacation, Returns January 2021
$38.50
Average Rating: Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating

Toffee, Almonds, Coconut and Semi-Sweet Chocolate THUMBNAIL
14 Cookies-Blue Chip Joy-A tasty delight with Coconut, Semi-Sweet Chips and Toffee.
On Vacation, Returns January 2021
$38.50

Blue Chip Royale (14 Cookies) THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
12 Cookies-Blue Chip Royale-Imperial tasting cookie with white chocolate, almonds and toffee!
Ship to multiple addresses
$38.50

Chocolate Chip, Semi-Sweet (14 Cookies) THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
14 Cookies~This legend has been named best chocolate chip cookie in 10 different cities and is the foundation of our cookie business for over 35 years! Real Guittard Semi-Sweet chocolates, we don't hold back on ingredients!
Ship to multiple addresses
$37.00
Average Rating: Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating

Chocolate Chip Macadamia Gourmet Cookies THUMBNAIL
14 Cookies-Chocolate Chip Macadamia-The Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie!
On Vacation, Returns January 2021
$38.50

Chocolate Chip M&M (14 Cookies) THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
14 Cookies-Chocolate Chip M&M is our chocolate chip cookies plus M&Ms added.
Ship to multiple addresses
$37.00

Chocolate Chip Walnut THUMBNAIL
Must be pre-ordered 2 shipping days in advance.
14 Cookies-Chocolate Chip Walnut-A Classic Winning Combination!
Ship to multiple addresses
$38.50

Snickerdoodle, Cinnamon Delight THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
14 Cookies-Cinnamon Delight-The Best Snickerdoodle in the world!
Ship to multiple addresses
$37.00
Average Rating: Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating

Lemon Cookie THUMBNAIL
14 Cookies- Delight in this light and airy cookie with that incredible lemon tang!
On Vacation, Returns January 2021
$38.50

milk chocolate chip gourmet cookies THUMBNAIL
14 Cookies-we take our traditional chocolate chip and replace the Guittard Semi-Sweet Chips with Guittard Milk Chocolate Chip.
On Vacation, Returns January 2021
$38.50

oatmeal raisin cookie THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
14 Cookies-Fresh oats, raisins and sprinkled with a touch of coconut makes Blue Chip's Oatmeal Raisin the best in the country!
Ship to multiple addresses
$38.50
Average Rating: Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Negative Rating Negative Rating

Peanut Butter Cookie THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
14 Cookies- Peanut Butter-Never tasted so good! Mom's Favorite.
Ship to multiple addresses
$37.00
Average Rating: Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating

Peanut Butter with Milk Chocolate THUMBNAIL
14 Cookies-Incredible combo of peanut butter and milk chocolate-14 cookies.
On Vacation, Returns January 2021
$38.50
Average Rating: Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating

Sugar Cookies THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
14 Sugar Cookies-Just the best sugar plain with light white sugar on top.
Ship to multiple addresses
$37.00

Sugar Cookies THUMBNAIL
12 Sugar Cookies with Buttercream Icing (sprinkles or no sprinkles)
On Vacation, Returns January 2021
$41.50
Average Rating: Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating

Sugar Cookies THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
14 Sugar Cookies with Sprinkles-We use fun sprinkles to go with season
Ship to multiple addresses
$37.00
Average Rating: Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating

Triple Chocolate Cookies THUMBNAIL
Specialty flavors could take 2 additional shipping day vs. core flavors.
14 Cookies-Triple Chocolate-A sinfully rich and delicious cookie made with 3 chocolates!
Ship to multiple addresses
$38.50
Average Rating: Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating

White Chocolate Chip Cookie THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
14 Cookies-White Chocolate is simply the white chips rolled into our special dough.
Ship to multiple addresses
$37.00
Average Rating: Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating

White Chocolate Macadamia Chip Cookie THUMBNAIL
Normal – Expected to ship tomorrow
14 Cookies- White Chocolate Macadamia-Our Signature Cookie
$38.50
Average Rating: Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating Positive Rating

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Fudge Icing THUMBNAIL
12 Cookies-Peanut Butter Cookies with Chocolate Icing
On Vacation, Returns January 2021
$41.50
Please Note: Our cookies have no preservatives and are made from scratch, the old-fashioned way. Upon receipt, we recommend you eat your cookies within 2 days or FREEZE right in their bags (do not refrigerate.)
513-697-6610
Returning Customer?
Privacy Policy Shipping Policy Return Policy
Shopping Cart
 

The Shopping Cart is currently empty

Coupon BeMerry is active View Remove
eCommerce Solution by Nexternal
Please Note: Our cookies have no preservatives and are made from scratch, the old-fashioned way. Upon receipt, we recommend you eat your cookies within 2 days or FREEZE right in their bags (do not refrigerate.)