‹ Continue Shopping

Secure Checkout

  • 1Log In or Register
  • 2Shipping & Billing Info
  • 3Review, Pay & Submit

Shop

Filter By

Cookie Lover
$ to$
(4)
(29)
Availability
Navigate:  Return to Storefront / Single Cookie Flavor Boxes

Want to know more about each flavor?

Order a single flavor in our signature box or seasonal box, get 2 cookies free. Certain cookies are only 12, because only 12 can fit in the box, price reflects 12.

Each flavor comes in our standard Blue Chip Cookies Box, you can upgrade if you would like to a designer wrap or a tin.  Simply add this to your shopping cart.

We have reduced our flavor selection due to the holiday season surge.  Flavors noted as "Returns in January" indicates that the flavor will return to website after January 5th, 2019.

Single Cookie Flavor Boxes

Best cookies delivered to your door
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Upgrade to Designer Theme Box-$1.00
Cookie Lover: $1.00

The Best Gourmet Cookies Delivered
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Upgrade to one of our holiday boxes.
Cookie Lover: $1.00

Corporate cookie gift tins.
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Upgrade from a gift box to one of our designer tins, holds up to 14 cookies.
Cookie Lover: $8.95

Corporate cookie gift tins.
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Upgrade from a gift box to one of our designer tins, holds up to 14 cookies.
Cookie Lover: $8.95

Almond Toffee Chip made with slivered almonds, toffee chocolate bits and Guittard Chocolate Semi-Sweet
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
FREE SHIPPING-14 Cookies-Almond Toffee-A cookie and candy in one!
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $38.50

Coconut, Brickle and Almnds
Free Shipping-14 Cookies-Blue Chip Joy-A tasty delight with Coconut, Semi-Sweet Chips and Toffee.
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $38.00

Blue Chip Royale--(14 Cookies)
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-14 Cookies-Blue Chip Royale-Imperial tasting cookie with white chocolate, almonds and toffee!
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $38.00

Best cookies online
Free Shipping-12 Cookies-The Black & White is a sinfully rich and delicious cookie made with bittersweet chocolate and white chocolate.
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $38.50

Chocolate Chip, Semi-Sweet (14 Cookies)
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Just want the best chocolate chip cookie? This legend has been named best chocolate chip cookie in 10 different cities and is the foundation of our cookie business for over 35 years! Real Guittard Semi-Sweet chocolates, we don't hold back on ingredients!
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $36.99

Chocolate Chip Macadamia Gourmet Cookies
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-14 Cookies-Chocolate Chip Macadamia-The Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie!
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $38.99

Chocolate Chip Mint (14 Cookies)
14 Cookies-Chocolate Chip Mint is our chocolate chip cookies Andes Mint added.
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $38.50

Chocolate Chip M&M (14 Cookies)
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-14 Cookies-Chocolate Chip M&M is our chocolate chip cookies plus M&Ms added.
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $37.50

Chocolate Chip Walnut
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-14 Cookies-Chocolate Chip Walnut-A Classic Winning Combination!
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $38.50

Snickerdoodle, Cinnamon Delight
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-14 Cookies-Cinnamon Delight-The Best Snickerdoodle in the world!
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $36.00

Coconut Chew-(14 Cookies)
14 Coconut Chew -The ultimate macaroon!
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $38.99

White chocolate and cranberries
Specialty flavors could take 1 additional shipping day vs. core flavors.
Free Shipping-14 Cookies-Cranberries & Cream-A must taste cookie!
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $38.00

Double Chocolate Chip (14 Cookies)
14 Cookies-Double Chocolate Chip is simply awesome!
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $38.50

White chocolate and semi sweet gourmet cookies
14 Cookies-The Blue Chip Dough with 2 great chocolate chip...the white and seimi-sweet
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $38.00

Lemon Cookie
14 Cookies- Lemon Delights
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $37.50

milk chocolate chip gourmet cookies
14 Cookies-Milk Chocolate Chip-A Hard To Find Cookie!
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $38.50

oatmeal raisin cookie
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-14 Cookies-Fresh oats, raisins and sprinkled with a touch of coconut makes Blue Chip's Oatmeal Raisin the best in the country!
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $37.50

Peanut Butter Cookie
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-14 Cookies- Peanut Butter-Never tasted so good! Mom's Favorite.
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $37.50

Peanut Butter with Milk Chocolate
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-14 Cookies-Incredible combo of peanut butter and milk chocolate-14 cookies.
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $38.50

Sugar Cookies
Free Shipping-12 Cookies-Peanut Butter Cookies with Chocolate Icing
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $39.99

Best Pumpkin Spice Cookies Shipped
14 Cookies-Cookie of the Month: Pumpkin Spice Cookies
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $37.50

Sugar Cookies
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
14 Sugar Cookies-Just the best sugar plain with light white sugar on top.
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $35.00

Sugar Cookies
Takes extra time to ice the cookies.
Free Shipping-12 Sugar Cookies with Buttercream Icing (sprinkles or no sprinkles)
Cookie Lover: $39.99

White chocolate and semi-sweet and milk chocolate cookie.
Free Shipping-14 Cookies-Triple Treat Cookies: Semi-Sweet, Milk Chocolate and White Chocolate!
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $38.50

Sugar Cookies
14 Cookies-Sugar Cookie with Seasonal M&Ms
Not Available-Returning in January
Cookie Lover: $37.50

Sugar Cookies
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-14 Sugar Cookies with Sprinkles-We use fun sprinkles to go with season
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $37.50

Triple Chocolate Cookies
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-12 Cookies-Triple Chocolate-A sinfully rich and delicious cookie made with 3 chocolates!
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $37.50

White Chocolate Chip Cookie
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-14 Cookies-White Chocolate is simply the white chips rolled into our special dough.
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $37.50

White Chocolate Macadamia Chip Cookie
FREE SHIPPING – Expected to ship tomorrow
Free Shipping-14 Cookies- White Chocolate Macadamia-Our Signature Cookie
How to ship to others
Cookie Lover: $38.99
Please Note: Our cookies have no preservatives and are made from scratch, the old-fashioned way. Upon receipt we recommend you eat your cookies within 2 days or FREEZE right in their bags (do not refrigerate.)
513-697-6610
Returning Customer?
Privacy Policy Shipping Policy Return Policy
Shopping Cart
 

The Shopping Cart is currently empty

eCommerce Solution by Nexternal
Please Note: Our cookies have no preservatives and are made from scratch, the old-fashioned way. Upon receipt we recommend you eat your cookies within 2 days or FREEZE right in their bags (do not refrigerate.)